Landmark YouTube Ripping Case Returns to Court for Another Round

  • The owner of YouTube-ripping websites “FLVTO.biz” and “2conv.com” will have to deal with music labels again.
  • The Fourth Court of Appeals decided that the platforms had a commercial exchange with Americans, so there are no jurisdiction issues.
  • The legal team of the defendant warns about the dangers that such a ruling would have for the global legal prosecution system.

The legal odyssey of YouTube-ripping websites “FLVTO.biz” and “2conv.com” is about to be resumed, as music record labels managed to reverse the last ruling on the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. But before we come to analyze the current state of affairs, let’s do a recap of how things developed in this case over the last two years to remind you of what happened.

Both YouTube ripping sites belong to a Russian man named Tofig Kurbanov. The first time he faced trouble was in August 2018, when Sony, Universal, and Warner Bros sued him and tried to take down his “piracy” websites. The man decided to take on a fight against these behemoths, and in January 2019, he got vindicated after a Virginia court dismissed the case due to jurisdiction issues. The music labels tried to present proof of the existence of commercial activity between US citizens and the ripping websites but failed to convince the court. In March 2019, the MPAA intervened and urged the Virginia District Court to reconsider the decision by filing an appeal, calling Kurbanov’s websites “quintessentially commercial.” And now, the Fourth Court of Appeals decided that there’s a basis on these claims, essentially overturning Virginia court’s ruling.

The reasoning was based on the fact that the defendant had approximately 1.5 million visitors from Virginia between October 2017 and September 2018. While the court failed to point to a concrete monetary exchange, it identified an extensive commercial-type relationship based on the deliverance of ads from the platform to its visitors. These repeated interactions and their monetary nature can be considered valid grounds for assuming the existence of commercial activity. Finally, the defendant had collaborations with American advertisers, and also bought services from US-based domain registrars and server infrastructure providers.

So, with the dismissal reversed, the legal battle can resume, but nothing is certain for either side. Kurbanov’s legal team stated that the decision sets a dangerous precedent, as the repercussions for foreign website operations are wide and deep. If this ruling stands, it will automatically open the channels of dragging people from the other side of the world in other countries’ courts. As they explain, just because a website happens to become popular in another country shouldn’t create a valid jurisdiction token. Based on this assumption, Americans could be called by Chinese or Russian courts, finding trouble in countries they have never visited or targeted in a particular manner.

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Recent Articles

5 Best VPN for Hong Kong in 2020 (Protect Yourself From The New National Security Law)

Without any doubt, Internet users in Hong Kong are in a very delicate situation right now. As you surely know, this previously independent territory...

How to Watch Quaker State 400 Online – Live Stream NASCAR Cup Series at Kentucky

We've got another NASCAR race on our hands, and the Quaker State 400 is just around the corner. We plan on watching the Quaker...

Seattle Police Booby-Trapped a File to Catch Ransomware Actor

An interesting method used by U.S. law enforcement authorities has been revealed. The FBI and the police use booby-trapped files that are...

Alleged Pirate Fights Copyright Trolls and Wins $4,420 Judgment

A filmmaker tried to push someone for a piracy settlement, but the defendant fought back. The plaintiff didn’t have enough evidence, so...

Apple Silicon Chips Expected to First Appear in MacBook Pro & MacBook Air Models – Followed by a Complete Redesign in 2021

Apple's ARM transition begins later this year, most probably with new MacBook Pro and MacBook Air laptops. Analysts predict an all-new MacBook Pro...